BC: MARVEL PREMIERE #30

Both my friend David Steckel and I were fans of THE INVADERS, the World War II-era comic book that writer/editor Roy Thomas had launched a short while earlier. Part of this was simply that the book included the original Human Torch–as we both loved FANTASTIC FOUR, this affection kind of transitioned over. Additionally, though, it somehow felt like INVADERS was important, like it was illuminating a key part of Marvel’s history. I don’t know that this was felt by everybody in fandom, but it sure seems like, when INVADERS launched, it must have performed well, because Roy almost immediately began setting up a second series set in that same timeframe, the Liberty Legion. They were the featured headliner in this issue of MARVEL PREMIERE which I borrowed from Steck in order to read it for myself.

Roy had originated the name Liberty Legion back when he was just a comic book crazy kid drawing up his own homemade comic books, and here he used it to describe a team comprised of lesser-known golden age Marvel heroes of the early 1940s. I had actually heard of a bunch of these guys before reading this issue, having pored over Jim Steranko’s HISTORY OF COMICS volume that covered the also-ran Timely characters. The Liberty Legion had a large membership, but some of these characters had only appeared a handful of times in books that were thirty years old (in a few cases, only one). Still, this gave Roy the license to rework them a bit to make them more to his liking. He rolled out the concept in two issues of MARVEL PREMIERE that crossed over with two early issues of INVADERS, making the team’s debut a massive four-part epic. The group was brought together by Bucky after the other Invaders had been captured and brainwashed by the Red Skull. And that’s about where this issue open.

I liked this Liberty Legion well enough, mainly due to the fact that it featured so many assorted super heroes. In that way, it felt akin to the annual Justice League/Justice Society team-ups. But sadly, the story itself is a bit of a dopey mess. We open with Bucky and the ductile Thin Man being attacked by a brainwashed Human Torch. The torch is able to easily get the better of the both of them, but his hypnotic conditioning isn’t strong enough to get him to kill them. One the fiery crusader returns to the Red Skull’s hidden headquarters, the Skull puts him under the will-bending Nullatron to get him and the other Invaders to the point where they’ll unleash chaos and catastrophe upon the Allied forces. The Skull himself has been posing as businessman Bettman P. Lyles, and it’s in that guise that he’s able to walk among the Liberty Legionnaires and learn their plans and progress.

In his Lyles guise, the Skull is horrified to learn that Toro, the Human Torch’s flaming companion, has been restored to himself after he was taken down by the Liberty Legion. But the Skull figures that Toro is the least of the Invaders, and so he chooses to step up his campaign of terror by broadcasting a challenge to the Legion to face his ensorcelled Invaders at Yankee Stadium. Rather than cordoning off the battleground, the next day the stand of Yankee Stadium are filled with a capacity crowd hoping to watch the Legion take down the Invaders (or, alternately, see the Legion get ground into the dust by Cap, Namor and the Torch.) The crowd treats this whole thing not as a deadly conflict that will determine the fate of nations, but rather like a sporting contest, where assorted bystanders talk about putting wagers on either team. It’s all sorta dopey.

Anyway, this is hardly a fair fight given that the Invaders number a mere three, whereas there are seven Legionnaires (plus Bucky and Toro, but they don’t take the field.) At the appointed time, the Invaders drop from the sky and the battle is joined. What follows is a typical Marvel punch-em-up of the era. At this time, it was typical for almost any Marvel story to devolve into several pages wherein a bunch of costumed heroes and villains traded blows and barbs with one another. Plotless? Sure. But the action-craving young readers of the period didn’t really know any better, myself included. There’s not an awful lot of specific business in this fight either, as the Invaders aren’t themselves, and the Liberty Legion is so large that each member only gets a panel or two of spotlight–hardly enough space to give them real personalities.

But as we get to the back pages of the book, after four issues we need to resolve the story in some fashion. So it turns out that Bucky has been dressed up as a stand-in for Toro out on the field, while the Yankees’ batboy has stood in for Bucky. (Why they didn’t just let the batboy be Toro and save Bucky the impersonation is a question too fundamental for small minds such as ours. Anyway, this was all in the service of making the Red Skull and his men think that Toro had been liberated from his Nullatron control, when really he’s just as mesmerized as ever. They had worked out that the Skull was posing as Lyles earlier, but rather than capturing him then, which would seem like the sane and sensible thing to do, they instead put on this pantomime about toro so that they could lure the Skull to the area. At this point, they wake up the real Toro, who is drawn by a homing instinct towards the Skull’s current headquarters in a zeppelin positioned high above Yankee Stadium. As Toro approaches, flame meets hydrogen and the entire ship explodes in a fiery ball, killing the Red Skull (not really–the Skull was adept at somehow surviving such catastrophes, though I don’t think we ever found out how he made it out of this one) and destroying the Nullatron.

From there, all that’s left is the clean-up. The Invaders snap back to themselves with the Skull’s equipment destroyed, and the Human Torch is able to catch Toro before he plummets to his death. The Liberty Legion themselves seem almost a bit surplus-to-requirements in this finale, apart from trading blows with the Invaders. But the more popular heroes give the Homefront newcomers their thumbs up, a sentiment that’s shared by the crowds of civilians in Yankee Stadium, so the Liberty Legion will be a going concern. Except that it wouldn’t. Roy was hoping to spin off a series, one was greenlit at one point but then cancelled before it could appear, with the pages produced for it being integrated into the INVADERS comic later on. The Legion would make a follow-up appearance in MARVEL TWO-IN-ONE in a crossover designed to help integrate INVADERS into the wider Marvel Universe, but that was it for them as a separate feature. And looking at this issue, I can understand why. Apart from their costumes, there isn’t anything much to any of these guys, certainly nothing that was going to hook a readership to want to see more. Roy liked them, though, so he’d continue to come back to a number of them in the months ahead.

30 thoughts on “BC: MARVEL PREMIERE #30”

  1. Finding out that people in the 1940s had their own comic book superheroes to read about was like finding out about dinosaurs, and like with dinosaurs ( which they are still discovering new species to this day ) I wanted to know more( The other heroes and the villains. I knew in my bones the Red Skull was not the only one ). To bad Roy Thomas didn’t use the JSA as a template and NOT DEPOWER MISS AMERICA or SLOWED DOWN the WHIZZER. That he didn’t look at the MAN WITH DIAMOND HARD SKIN and see a SUPERMAN or HUGO DANNER. Maybe had he gone with his Nick and Nora Charles ( The Thin Man movies and novel(s) ) with the THIN MAN and OLALLA and treated them as Science Detectives and the DC COMICS Hawkman & Hawkgirl team or Ant-Man/Giant-Man/Goliath/Yellowjacket and the Wasp team — the Thin Man & Olalla had that cool advanced plane. RED RAVEN more powerful than his Timely Comics version, thanks to the energy beams from his wing tips.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. Nick and Nora Charles weren’t science detectives, I just meant to use them as a team and using the Thin Man and Olalla’s background as the science detectives part.

      Liked by 1 person

    2. Roy Thomas mind-controlled heroes story [ The Avengers#53 ( June 1968 ) Magneto lures the Avengers to his island base to fight off the invading X-Men. Even after mind-controlling the X-Men into hating the Avengers, the two teams outwit Magneto and team up to defeat him — a crossover story that started in X-Men#45 ( June 1968 ) –comics.org ] and [ All-Star Squadron#4 ( December 1981 ) On the way to destroy the Japanese Fleet that attacked Pearl Harbor, those most vulnerable to magic come under the influence of the Holy Grail, in the possession of Tojo ( and agent Dragon King ). Just as the Spear of Destiny gives Hitler control over the heroes in Europe, the Grail puts the heroes under the control of Japan. As the controlled heroes fight those still free, Dr. Fate pursues Hawkman outside the reach of the Grail, comes to his senses, and sends the Winged Wonder to lure the others to safety –comics.org ]. MIGHT HAVE SAID THIS BEFORE: I can’t help but wonder if the Mind-Controlled Invaders plot wasn’t inspired by Fawcett Comics Spy Smasher brainwashing plot [ Whiz Comics#15-18 ( March-June 13, 1941 ) — the Mask used the Brainograph to brainwash Spy Smasher into an evil menace to democratic society ]. Since the Liberty Legion knew Bettman P. Lyles was the Red Skull, if they weren’t going to capture him, then Roy should have had the Legion set their trap somewhere secluded ( Mention that the military wanted the Legion to provide security for some new mystery weapon/technology/alloy ).

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I don’t recall Magneto mind-controlling the X-men when the Avengers come in response to Angel’s escape and request that they come aid/free the X-men. The entire fight in Avengers #53 was a ruse, after they spied Cyclops and Quicksilver fighting, but they allegedly guessed correctly that Magneto was watching their every move.

        Like

      2. Kirk G’ go to marvel.fandom.com it says Magnetp mentally dominated the X-Men, Ctcops has found the rest of the imprisoned X-Men and frees them. But just then, they are overwhelmed by Magneto’s mind-control device that turns them into rampaging killing machines.

        Like

  2. boy, that sure is a lot of colletta’s reductive embellishing in the bhoc this weekend, perhaps i need a little tom palmer to cleanse the palate : )

    Like

  3. I was one of those Invaders fans who could not wait for this issue to hit the spinner racks in “Sawmill Central.” Unfortunately, the final product struck me as being a few tomato slices short of Skinny’s Special from Carl’s Pizza. As much as I wanted Don Heck’s art to fit this team just as Frank Robbins did for the “A-Team,” he and Colletta ranked only an “OK” for me. But what really held the Liberty Legion behind was the overall generic nature of the various team members. I felt more like they were set up by powers than personality. Stretchy guy. Icy dude. And that fast guy and tough lady who are supposed to get together so that they can become the parents of the Scarlet Witch and Quicksilver.

    Would I have purchased the Liberty Legion had they been given their own series? Yeah. Would I have stuck with it? Who knows.

    Liked by 3 people

    1. Roy Thomas has Whizzer end up with Miss America [ Giant-Size Avengers#1 ( August 1974 ) ] and Johnny Quick end up or start a relationship with Liberty Belle in the All-Star Squadron series. At least it was different writers that had hero archers be in a relationship with female bird named heroes ( Green Arrow and Black Canary — Hawkeye and Mockingbird ).

      Liked by 2 people

  4. As you say, this is pretty much Bog Standard Marvel Plot #257, but I really dug it as a kid. I knew a fair amount about DC’s golden age heroes (thanks to reprints), but these guys were all new to me, and I was immediately intrigued. I always liked Bucky, so seeing him take charge was fun. It’s just a solid, meat-and-potatoes comic book adventure. Sticks to your ribs. 😀

    Don Heck was never my favorite, but (much like Frank Robbins), his style seemed like a good fit for the 1940s milieu. And that cover is great — I don’t know if that’s a Kirby design, or whether Marie Severin or someone did the layout for him, but it does a great job of fitting in all those characters without it getting crowded.

    Liked by 4 people

    1. Since Kirby wouldn’t have had the actual issue to work from, it was almost certainly roughed out by someone at Marvel — if I had to guess who it’d be Dave Cockrum rather than Marie, but I could easily be wrong.

      Liked by 2 people

  5. I remember buying this and liking it but not liking liking it. I think the art was what let me down the most. At the time, I didn’t know much about the Timely Also Rans, the ones that lasted 1-4 stories and then were gone, so it was interesting to learn about.

    After learning more, years later, I was sorry that they didn’t bring in the Fin to go against Namor. The Angel was probably the longest running 2nd tier hero in the Timely universe and I would have loved to seen him. Would have loved to see the ones that actually last 6+ stories, though also remembering the time line of early 40s, so Blonde Phantom and Namora would have been out, too early for them.

    Liked by 2 people

    1. When it comes to Blonde Phantom [ All Select Comics#11 ( Fall 1946 ) ] 1946 might be her first comic appearance, but she was already public known to the people of the Timely Comics Universe, plus in that issue Mark Mason was a OSS agent and the O.S.S. was officially dissolved on October 1, 1945. As for Namora, she could be active mostly at see during WW2 like the Fin in his Timely Comics story.

      Like

      1. Miss America [ Marvel Mystery Comics#49 ( November 1943 ) “Scourge of the Nazis” –her origin is in this issue making 1943 when she was active –this was no flashback ] was moved from being active in 1943 to either late 1941 or early 1942.

        Liked by 1 person

  6. I loved the punch ups when I was a kid. I remember this issue well. Always loved the Liberty Legion. Back in the day I hoped they would get an ongoing.

    Liked by 1 person

  7. I’d be really interested who was working with colletta at that point, because some of these inks strongly remind me of other people (and some faces look nothing like cousin Vinnie’s usual fare at all).

    Like

  8. The thing is, we DID get to see a Liberty Legion ongoing — just a few years later at another company. Roy’s Thomas’ All-Star Squadron (particularly the heroes he chose to highlight) WERE the Liberty Legion in all but name. Consider:
    Both teams had:
    –the speedster having a bickering/loving relationship with the patriotically-themed woman (Whizzer/Miss America = Johny Quick/Liberty Belle);
    –the non-adventurer scientist turned super-strong hero (Blue Diamond =Robotman)
    –the flag-clad athlete (Patriot = Commander Steel)
    — the stretching hero who works for the FBI (Thin Man = Plastic Man)
    — the winged hero (Red Raven = Hawkman)
    — the temperature-themed hero (Jack Frost = Firebrand…who was named after Roy’s new WIFE!)
    — the teenage athlete (Bucky = Atom)

    All-Star Squadron later drew on a larger cast, because DC had a larger number of longer-lasting, more interesting heroes; but the “main characters” were pretty much the same.

    Liked by 1 person

  9. I got this and liked it. Colletta does a serviceable ink job on Heck…. who’s a decent fit for the time period of the material. I think a Liberty Legion ongoing that fleshed out otherwise blank slate characters could have been potentially more interesting than the Invaders… a title that had entertaining action but struggled to create much in the way of story momentum. I think it would have been cool if plots from the WWll era could have been seeded into the current MU someway somehow?

    Liked by 4 people

  10. Those last two panels of the issue certainly feel alot like the end to several Avengers that I read over the silver age… I’m thinking of either the ending of #22 or maybe #45 when they declare Avengers Day.

    Liked by 1 person

  11. I really liked the Liberty Legion. I don’t think I’d read the Steranko History yet, but a big part of the appeal of Marvel’s comics for me was the way they connected and made up a universe, so it was fun to learn more about the 1940s heroes and get a larger sense of that universe. Also, the LL had a variety of personalities and a budding romance (plus some clear friendships a-borning), which was also a big part of my interest in ongoing series. So it was very much the kind of thing I liked to see.

    I mentioned the other day that I think Don Heck generally survived Vince Colletta pretty well, and this two-parter is the first thing I think of to back that up. It’s not as strong as Heck with some other inkers could be, but the solidity that often gets lost when Vinnie inked someone else is fairly well present, here. I own the original art to the first page of this story (in the previous issue), and I’m very glad to have it.

    I would have liked to have seen more of them, but I kinda think I got that in ALL-STAR SQUADRON, where Johnny Quick and Liberty Belle’s romance seems to have been a continuation of the Whizzer and Miss America’s here, and the general personality and style of this series seemed to be the model for that one even moreso than INVADERS.

    Liked by 4 people

  12. Tom, was the Blue Diamond from Delaware? 😉 The “Diamond State”. Their semi-pro baseball team is called the Blue Rocks (though wouldn’t that be saphire?)…

    Liked by 1 person

  13. First, a reappraisal. A month ago Tom posted about The Invaders #16 and there were a number of comments about guest penciller Jim Mooney’s artwork vs. regular penciller Frank Robbins’ artwork. I ended up reading issues #16-21 so I could get the entire story. Afterwards, in my comment on the post, I stated that I found Frank’s pencils almost grotesque. This issue is the last one of a four-parter and The Invaders #5 looked like it followed on from ##4 (it didn’t), so I just went to issue #1 and read The Invaders #1-#6, plus the Marvel Premiere #29-30. I found Frank’s pencils on issues #1-4 and #6 to be generally enjoyable and his faces on the Nazi’s to far less distorted then on the later issues. I’ll have to read more issue to see which issues better reflect his work.

    As for this issue of Marvel Premiere #30, It’s a decent wrap-up to the story, but I don’t feel it’s as good as it should have been. Then again, all issue #29 did was introduce us to each of the soon be Liberty Legion members. The story probably could have been a cracking two-parter. That said, I like the LL enough that I started reading Marvel Two-in-One Annual #1 (I stopped to write this comment).

    Liked by 1 person

    1. If you didn’t like the art on issues 16-21, but liked it better on 1-6, then what you’re probably reacting to is the inking, since Vince Colletta inked the early issues and Frank Springer the later ones.

      Springer is more in tune with the pencils, and Robbins fans generally like his inks better than Vinnie’s. But Roy has said that the sales dropped when Springer came aboard, so Robbins fans may not be the best judge of commercial appeal.

      Me, I like Springer’s inks more, but I far prefer Robbins’ own inks.

      Liked by 1 person

      1. I’m aware of the importance of inkers, and if I wasn’t there’s been a fair amount of discussion about inkers in the comments to Tom’s posts. I’ll admit I didn’t look at who the inker was on these early issues, as I was more interested in reading the stories.

        Your comment about liking Robbins inking his own pencils does make me curious to see it. Can you point me to a few issues that he inked his own pencils?

        Like

      2. My memories are mostly of his Marvel art, including one page that has never left me when most of that year I have to be reminded of. I loved everything of his I bought. From comments here and elsewhere, I think I’m a real minority that found his art sexy as well.

        Like

      3. I prefer Springer inks over Colletta on Robbins, but that said… Giant-Size Invaders #1 blew my 9 year old mind…and it was inked by Colletta. I loved it. I probably would have loved it more if Springer inked it I guess.

        Like

  14. Well if the All-Star Squadron was Roy Thomas second attempt at a Liberty Legion series, then these Timely Comics villains could take the place of some of the All-Star Squadron foes ( Dr. Hastor( I see Zeelmo, Ratoga & Star-Gazer as possible answer to him ) & Akhet, Monocle( Star-Gazer has a lens that shoots starlight & Star Monster isn’t a android but a Solam — Captain Marvel#6 ( October 1968 ) ), Real American ( The Hood isn;t a racist or robot ), Monster, Psycho-Pirate II( Dr. Fear limited to fear ), Black Dragon Society/Dragon King, Baron Blitzkrieg ( Professor Lawson isn’t a Nazi ), Catwoman, Oom the Mighty. Power Stone & Kulak( Kulak wasn’t a 4-armed Idol ) : Zeelmo & Ratoga ( criminal scientists with advanced technology ) [ Red Raven Comics#1 ( August 1940 ) Red Raven story ], Star-Gazer & Star Monster [ Mystic Comics#3 ( June 1940 ) Blue Blaze story ], The Hood ( Willard Thomas ) [ Mystic Comics#3 ( June 1940 ) Dynamic Man story — The Hood & The Order of the Hood in All-Winners Comics#1 ( Summer 1941 ) Black Marvel story ], The Grinner ( Dr. Weems -a Mr. Hyde-like monster ) [ Mystic Comics#7 ( December 1941 ) Black Marvel story ], Dr. Fear ( scare people to death ) [ Mystic Comics#8 ( March 1942 ) Blazing Skull story ], Black Dragon Society( Micka ( head ) ) [ All-Winners Comics#3 ( Winter 1941-42 ) Human Torch & Toro story ]. Professor Lawson ( he suppose to have the same powers as Miss America )[ Marvel Mystery Comics#49 ( November 1943 ) Miss America story ], The Cat’s Paw [ Mystery Comics#18-20 ( April-June1941 ) Angel story ] . The Demon ( the embodiment of mankind’s evil )[ Mystic Comics#7-10( December 1941-1942 ) Davey and the Demon story ] — I suggested before shrinking him down to Hulk size increasing his durability ( I saw Davey Drew as Timely’s Rick Jones to a Demonic Giant Hulk ). Blooded Ruby of Chung [ Mystic Comics#1 ( March 1940 ) Dakor the Magician story ]. Cool Jack Kirby & Joe Simon(?) villains( deadly monster in Hitler’s Trunk of Terror & that 4-armed Idol ) on the cover [ Mystic Comics#7 ( December 1941 ) Destroyer foes ]

    Like

Leave a Reply